Manitoba Reserve Chief's Pay Rivals Premier
Chief and council's pay range for 535 person reserve: $106,000-144,000
CTF renews call for placing all reserve council salaries on the internet
The Canadian Taxpayers Federation (CTF) released more brown envelope documents today as part of its campaign for transparency of band council salaries. The documents show pay levels for the band council's four positions at the 535 person Ochi-Chak-Ko-Sipi First Nation (Crane River) ranged from $106,000-$144,000 (taxable equivalent) for 2008-09, plus travel.
“There are 535 people on the reserve and yet band council members made taxable salaries equivalent to $106,000-$144,000” said Colin Craig, Prairie Director for the CTF. “That’s just not right. The average person on the reserve makes around $20,000. Imagine how many people on the reserve could have been put through training programs with those funds.”
By comparison, Manitoba's MLAs earned $83,722 in 2008 while the Premier earned $152,147.
In addition to band council pay, the average council position incurred $23,210 in travel expenses. It is not clear how such high expenditures were justified.
Documents provided to the CTF also included audit information which shows a reserve deficit of $506,825 for 2008-09, a debt of $1,189,782 and several troubling comments from the auditor:
“Chief and Council did not understand the budget and how it was to be used.”
“Employees were not penalized for not showing up to work or for not doing their jobs in a reasonable time frame.”
“Communication between the Accounting staff and Chief and Council was not sufficient as Chief and Council did not understand what the Accounting staff was doing to keep the First Nation operating.”
“This is the third brown envelope we have received from concerned band members in the recent past,” added Craig. “People are crying out, they want transparency. The government should change whatever legislation it has to in order to put the information on the internet for all to see.”
To view the documents, click here.
Canada's Federal Debt
Your Share
The federal government is adding $58 million a day to our debt. By 2015-16, the debt is slated to hit $614 billion. Support our campaign for balanced federal budgets and help us STOP this clock.
Spokespeople & Blog
In five provinces and Ottawa a team of dedicated professionals is standing up to special interests, ensuring that taxpayers' voices are being heard.
In The News
-
How much do Canadians pay in taxes?
read more » -
BC gas taxes highest in Canada
read more » -
BC government's PR firms
read more » -
HST and Carbon tax reason for BC government's unpopularity
read more » -
TransLink executives receive big bonuses
read more » -
Reforming gold-plated MP Pensions
read more » -
Questions raised on flood relief funding to Peguis First Nations
read more » -
More taxes in 2012 Manitoba Budget
read more » -
Photo Radar Busted in Winnipeg!
read more » -
Big pay for transit police
read more » -
Free the Fishermen from Freshwater Fish Marketing Corporation
read more » -
TransLink executives receive big bonuses
read more » -
Two bills introduced in Ontario legislature to protect taxpayers
read more » -
Host of new tax increases for BC
read more » -
Questionable expenses at Freshwater Fish Marketing Corp
read more » -
TransLink has lost $230 million due to unpaid fares!
read more » -
TransLink's fare evasion problems
read more » -
TransLink can't collect its fines
read more » -
NS: NDP Promise of Tax Reductions, a “Welcome Relief” says CTF
read more » -
Sask Film Tax Credit Briefing
read more » -
Should there be cuts in the size of Canada’s federal public Service?
read more » -
CCPA calls for massive spending increases in federal budget
read more » -
Are attack ads on Bob Rae legit?
read more » -
Is TransLink Police force a waste of money?
read more »



























Comments
Transparency-accountability Chief's Salaries
Want to know where it boils out of?...INAC....Indian & Northern Affairs allows this type of corruption to exist. Where is the accountability in that? I am a member of an Interlake Band (Pinaymootang First Nation). Our Interlake Reserves Tribal Council (IRTC) is an invisible organization; to me I look at it as 'organized crime'. When you approach the tribal council of enquiries, they tell you to go and ask your chief. This is not good governance, as the chief will not release any information. This organization is a flow through for INAC funding and does not benefit any IRTC community. Only the Chiefs and their families benefit from this organization. Can you imagine how many tax dollars line the Chief's pockets. This organization also has shares from the Tribal Council Investment Group; how much funding does IRTC recieved from TCIG annually? Only the Chiefs know. Our band members cannot access Economic Development Dollars from IRTC. When you approach INAC to access this information, they tell you to ask your chief. This is a dead-end road. I am sure that IRTC band members would like to know how much tax dollars are being spent combining band funds and IRTC funds on their Chiefs. How much is each Chief receiving annually from both these organizations combined?
"Accountiblity-band funds are
"Accountiblity-band funds are public funds and therefore should be open to the public especially band members" who are requesting the financial information. Usually these pleas fall upon deaf ears of some of the elected band officials who were voted by members to do their best for their band as a whole and to not only serve those whom they think voted for them..."Show me the money" or rather where it is and whom is it really benefitting?
DJK
Piapot First Nation #75
Tobique
Sorry, approximately 1300 on reserve.
We need help taxpayers!
Tobique First Nation beats DTES Vancouver along with 6 other NB RESERVATIONS as one of the nations "POOREST COMMUNITIES in the COUNTRY". The study was taken in 2006, we have since discovered our $40 MILLION + DEBT with an UNacounted CASINO.
UNACCOUNTED casino and 4 suicides in five years.
Also the former chief is now N.B. Deputy Aboriginal Sect., and finally we also have the Lietentant Gov. of N.B. from Tobique Last Nation.
With that lineup ... if we can't make it then we don't know who the F can!
What's worse is that the administration wont allow the RCMP to further investigate the forensic investigation????
We know exactly how taxpayers feel when all this funding for good only went to a few for their personal interests. $40 Mill Population 2000. Taxpayers, help us get to the truth!
desperate changes needed
The Chief and council (elected by band members) should be there for the community and the 535 on reserve and are they? Or are they laughing all the way to the bank? They do not deserve to be there, it should be equal pay for equal work. Time to elect a new chief and council. How can someone honestly be worth paying themselves over One Hundred THousand dollars meanwhile children, youth, teens, elders are suffering. There's NO programs for them and yet this reserve receives so much funding to help there band members. The welfare system is so crooked, people are recieving welfare meanwhile they should be out finding work or the band should get these people trained and put them to work so they can have better lives for themselves and thier families. This would better the community overall. I hope it would anyway.
As for the previous comment that Chief, you can find him sitting in front of the local VLT machines 24 7, thats the truth, ask any band member on reserve. How about having band membership meetings that are constantly requested and has never happened in years.
INAC should enforce rules, policies and procedures for band elections, this process is so crooked its shameful.
INAC should also enforce a condition that there should be a minimum education level for chiefs and councillors so at least they can understand a simply budget and would not have Auditors making comments as such.
Time for Changes....come on government help them out for a change...instead of turning away. Band members are desperate and shouting as loud as they can, will you hear them?
It needs to be pointed out
It needs to be pointed out that people on the reserve approached us about the salaries as they're upset with what's going on.
Second, politicians, not matter what their ethnicity, should not be allowed to set their own pay - that's a conflict of interest.
chief salaries
I'm sorry. A salary of 105,000 ?. MLA's live off reserve, and have independent resources from previous employment. Chiefs often do not. Also consider the difference in culture. The Chief will 'spread the wealth' such as it is, whereas MLA's consider their salaries their own. (Of course!) The reservation we lived on was fly in. Any 'meeting' involved someone flying in, or flying out. Technology was difficult to maintain. Goods came in on the winter road (on ice).
$105,000? Check what the teachers on reserves make. They get isolation pay, travel bonus, signing bonus... because otherwise they wouldnt go!
$105,000? The Chiefs are 'on duty' and on the spot, easily accessible and easy to find, 24/7. Know any MLA's like that? They have life and death crises daily. Know any MLA's with that much contact with responsibility?
$105,000? I would hope so!
Want to work on something, work on the money wasted on reserves because money sent for (for example) education has strings attached requiring the hiring of 'recommended' consusltants... hundreds of thousands of dollars in consultant fees that the same guys collect for handing in the same 'reports' on multitude reserves...former fed employees and friends.
Find a way to get some work going up there... the $20,000 'salary' is welfare- NOT salary. And training programs to train for work not available (nothing is there) is a waste of money, except to provide work... that sort of thing already happens plenty!
Reading a report and getting het up about it takes no intelligence. Finding solutions to real problems may be beyond possibility in the current set up. Now there's something to write about.
Many problems exist in our first nation communies
Our first nation communities are all playing catch up everyone knows what is available to the rest of the world is not available to our people. Over the past hundreds of years our people have survived many atrocities many hidden and done in secret. These things are hardly ever spoken of. I say there is a light at the end of the tunnel for our people. I personally have come up with ways to eradicate many problems that exist on our reserves, but no one will hear me out. So i am on a personel journey to do whatever it takes to help with these problems and many many others that exist. I am A FIRST NATION WOMAN WHO CARES. Creator put me on this earth to help my people and that is what i am gonna do. I totally agree with what is being said here and i understand our peoples plight but if we have faith and work together our nation of people will surprise the world one day we have to believe that throughout all of our suffering and dilemas we can overcome all of this to show the world that we are survivors and no matter what is thrown at us we can overcome it. Look back in our history and remember what our ansestors endured and how they survived. My great grandmother survived the small pox epidemic, She walked out of the bush after watching her mother die on the beach holding her little sister, her mothers last words to her was run get away from here your not sick don't come here go...my great kookoo just had to stand there and watch her mamma go... she was only 8 or 9 yrs of age. There was a documentory done on this story of mine but at the time i was ignorent of many things and the woman at U of M who done her thesis on this story sold it to the highest bidder and a made for tv movie was done on my great kookoo's story. I never heard from this woman again,Nor did i see any of the money she made. I use this experience in my life and the story that was passed down to my family too always remember that our people survived for a reason and there are many other storys out there that i am sure similar to mine. Our passed on elders are watching us, We need to make them proud....By doing whatever it takes.
Post new comment