BC tax cuts make the HST truly revenue neutral

The Canadian Taxpayers Federation (CTF) has crunched the numbers and the changes flowing from BC's move to the HST are now truly revenue neutral. BC Premier Gordon Campbell's move to cut taxes on income below $73,000 by 15% will ensure that families projected to take a hit from HST will either come out ahead or break even.

BC HST 2

Economists have supported the HST for its efficiencies in the economy. Businesses have supported the HST for its simplification. The CTF was hesitant to support the HST because it was a net tax increase on most families, and the way in which it was thrust on voters without discussion during an election or a referendum.

With these taxes cuts, the CTF's first concern has been addressed. Attention must now be turned to the second. With a referendum scheduled to decide the fate of the HST next year, no one will be able to claim that it is a tax-grab. Rather, there is still legitimate anger about the way in which the HST was thrust on voters. A more positive channel for this anger would be to demand from politicians a Taxpayer Protection Act modeled on what Ontario had; that is, before Dalton McGunity gutted it. This would require a refferendum every time a government wishes shift or raise taxes unless it has a clear mandate to do so in an election.

Premier Campbell has now done what he should have done the day the HST was introduced: make it revenue neutral or positive for families. The only outstanding issue now the timing of the day he first introduced it.

By: Derek Fildebrandt
Posted: October 29, 2010
Topic: British Columbia

Bookmark and Share Join Us   |   Donate

Comments

HST

I'm just curious, hasn't anyone else clued into the fact that the HST will still have a negative impact on people because the government will be taxing more items than they were taxing before this whole fiasco started. There are things that were not taxed before the HST was implemented that will remain taxed even if the HST is reduced to 10%. THE HST WILL NEVER BE REVENUE NEUTRAL NO MATTER HOW HARD THE GOVERNMENT TRIES TO FORCE THIS DOWN YOUR THROAT PERIOD! Since when has the government EVER reduced taxes particularly to the benefit of middle and lower class taxpayers? IT JUST DOES NOT HAPPEN (not in this country anyway)!

%15 income tax cut

CTF has to get on this for us BCers, we were offered a bribe to make the HST revenue neutral, but when Gordo didn't get the result he wanted he had to stab us in the back again.  We need CTF now more than ever, at least until the recalls begin and heads roll...

Revenue neutral, not really

Now factor in the various new taxes (carbon trust, tax on motor fuel, carbon taxes and LEED requirements on new buildings). Not to mentioned massive ferry fare increases, BC Hydro increases. Neutrality gets imbalanced again.

I'm looking for a used car. 

I'm looking for a used car.  If I buy it from a private seller I used to pay 7% PST.  Now I pay a 12% "new mystery tax" they drempt up because HST doesn't apply to private sales.  That's not revenue neutral.

If I buy my used car in the USA, I will pay the HST (12%) at the border, but maybe now will have to pay another 12% "new mystery tax" when I try to insure it.  

How is this good for me......the voter. 

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Canada's Federal Debt

Your Share

The federal government is adding $58 million a day to our debt. By 2015-16, the debt is slated to hit $614 billion. Support our campaign for balanced federal budgets and help us STOP this clock.

View Debt »

Spokespeople & Blog

In five provinces and Ottawa a team of dedicated professionals is standing up to special interests, ensuring that taxpayers' voices are being heard.

View all spokespeople »
Go to Blog »

In The News

 

 

Sign-Up

Join with over 70,000 Canadian taxpayers. Get instant action updates and make a difference.

64,232

Donate
Take Action

Vimeo video Facebook Twitter RSS Feed YouTube Channel